Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Singing in the Rain's "Broadway Melody"


In the film Singing in the Rain, there is a section called “Broadway Melody”. It is made in a completely different style from the rest of the movie; it is far more cartoony than the rest of the film, which is quite realistic. “Broadway Melody” even features a new character, a woman in a green dress, who is not in any of the other scenes in the rest of the movie. The woman is the reason that Don Lockwood’s character in the scene goes through the rest of the scene. He essentially does a bunch of dancing and singing. This is a clip of Don Lockwood's actor dancing with the woman in green.
 
All this scene really does is show off the actor who plays Don Look wood’s’ character. While he is the protagonist, it really is just too much of him for the film to flow well. It has no real effect on the rest of the movie in anyway plot-wise, and no real discernible meaning. The director should have cut it from the movie and instead used a scene that actually had relevance to the plot in the film.

1 comment:

  1. I love the way you're including multimedia in your posts to illustrate and back up your points. It's helpful, looks professional, and easy to do, right?

    I'm not going to argue against your reasoning, but provide some more background. Most people consider the 1943 musical Oklahoma! to be the first musical to completely have original songs that either advanced the plot or character. Prior to then and for a while afterward, it was natural to have songs and dances in the show just because they were good showcases for the performers. The "Moses Supposes" is another illustration of that mindset from this movie. So audiences in 1952 would not have been as bothered by the tangential nature of this number as we are in 2012.

    ReplyDelete